For some reason my offer happens resistant to the first and you may fundamental place off marriage, but even if we are in favor of relationships, as it is fitting of men exactly who generate rules for all of us, we should silently consider best hookup bar Shreveport mans true situation. Looking at you to legislation comes of reality, this type of males provides joined here to type a structure and therefore wipes clean the brand new errors of history and you can tries a different roadway money for hard times, [thus] it is necessary which they judiciously analysis the criteria your landscaping and you can visited the finish that there exists something for the our everyday life plus in our society to which we can’t for the in whatever way close our very own vision, that individuals need certainly to deal with valiantly. 51
Hernandez reasoned you to definitely simple legal sanction away from a sexual union you may never be really the only research that any particular one are a proper and ethical resident
We have come to this new Assembly to help you meagerly guard, into best of my personal element, the fresh new Cuban lady, the fresh new partnered girl, the latest single lady, the fresh white woman, the latest black woman, lady of all of the classes. I must point out that there is a large number of Cuban ladies in difficult and you will humiliating situations, that as respectable so when worthy of quality because the was most other female, that just because the she is when you look at the a free partnership, doesn’t mean that people should consider the woman and her family immoral. 52
Of the asserting one a great disjuncture resided ranging from legislators’ beliefs and “societal fact,” Hernandez argued one she was fighting getting Cubans who had been maybe not commonly reported to be types of sexual propriety and you will, hence, was unjustly disenfranchised
Twenty-a couple of out from the 60-half a dozen Assembly players likely to the brand new example chosen so you’re able to agree Hernandez’s offer. A lot of those who voted within the favor reasoned this manage assist males inside consensual unions to meet a comparable responsibilities and you can responsibilities one partnered guys have been bound to satisfy and you may, hence, create manage all women and children. Such as, progressive Construction user Capablanca contended you to definitely “though it [Hernandez’s modification] appears paradoxical, far from being…an attack into the wedding, it’s a shelter of it.” 53 He explained, “When boys know that he’s guilty of females which have just who he’s got an effective consensual partnership and also for the college students you to effects from the 100 % free unions, chances are they doesn’t take part in consensual unions but in relationship.” 54 Capablanca represented men while the almost inherently irresponsible, and you will created that women requisite State protection from her or him. Other people echoed his rationale.
However, most System players, progressives and traditionals, balked during the Hernandez’s idea, arguing that it was maybe not conducive to help you popular progress and you may create offer liberties and you can benefits to undeserving, immoral residents. Antique Construction associate Cortina contributed good demanding endeavor up against Hernandez’s offer, framing his dissent while the a fight to own modernity, progress, and you will culture. He mentioned that a good constitutional ensure to adopt consensual unions similar to judge marriage ceremonies would basically publish Cuba from towards a legal highway divergent of regarding “all of the gentle places in the world” and you can “damage…this new matrimonial program, and come up with [it] totally useless.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “When it modification was indeed recognized, we could possibly write a large distress when you look at the courtroom marriage, and now we manage use the effects of the governmental trend and that i have simply stayed courtesy, in order to groups of your emotional and you may friends existence, [sectors] and that won’t need to getting transformed on radical and you can perturbing way that is actually advised.” 56 Having Cortina, the brand new 1933 revolution try a political revolution, and you can then change is to only apply to government: Societal issues are kept alone.